Recent advances in technology allow doctors to more precisely control the angle and intensity of radiation directed at a tumor site.
With traditional radiation, however, it is still difficult for radiologists to target mesothelioma. This type of cancer typically forms near vital organs that are extremely vulnerable to radiation damage.
For pleural mesothelioma, these organs include the lungs, heart and liver. For pericardial mesothelioma, they include the intestines, kidneys and other organs of the gut. The esophagus, spine and bone marrow are all sensitive to radiation damage as well.
Proton therapy offers one solution to this problem.
Proton Therapy Facts
- Allows radiologists to safely administer higher doses of radiation
- Reduces risk of radiation damage to vital organs
- Can replace traditional radiation in a multimodal treatment plan
- Available only at specialized cancer treatment centers
By using a beam of protons — rather than a conventional beam of photons — radiologists can reduce the amount of radiation healthy tissues receive. The result is a radiation treatment with a lower risk of complications and potentially greater effectiveness.
Proton therapy is best suited for treating a localized, early-stage tumor. When combined with chemotherapy and surgery as part of a multimodal treatment approach, proton therapy has proven at least as effective as traditional radiation.
There is not enough hard data yet to say whether proton therapy is more effective than other types of radiation therapy for mesothelioma. Early reports from pioneering doctors and cancer survivors suggest the technology shows promise. This therapy is not common for mesothelioma, but some radiologists prefer it over other methods.
Dr. Joe Chang MD Anderson Cancer Center Department of Radiation Oncology
“The proton beam provides much more conformal radiation, which means higher doses to tumors and lower dosages to critical structures nearby.”
Learn About COVID-19 and Mesothelioma
Get a free recording of the COVID-19 and mesothelioma presentation hosted by the experts at The Mesothelioma Center.Get Yours Now
Proton Versus Traditional Radiation Therapy
Proton therapy and traditional radiation therapy share many of the same basic features.
Similarities Between Proton Therapy and Traditional Radiation
- Both seek to damage cancer-cell DNA, preventing reproduction or causing cell death.
- Both types of radiation can be “intensity modulated,” which means a computer controls precisely how much radiation is aimed at each part of the tumor.
- The treatments are quick and painless, with each session typically lasting less than an hour and causing only mild side effects.
The differences between the two treatments come from the types of energy involved.
Traditional radiation uses photons, which are what X-rays, radio waves and visible light rays are made of. Protons, on the other hand, are one of the basic building blocks of matter, along with neutrons and electrons.
Photon and proton beams interact with a cancer patient’s body in distinct ways.
|Photons (Traditional Radiation)||Protons|
|Deposit much of their energy as soon as they enter the body||Deposit only a small fraction of their energy when they enter the body|
|Deposit some of their energy in the tumor, but not as much as in the healthy tissue in front of the tumor||Slow down and come to a stop in the tumor, where they deposit all their remaining energy|
|Deposit some of their remaining energy in the healthy tissue behind the tumor and then exit the body on the other side||Leave the healthy tissue behind the tumor mostly unaffected|
With traditional radiation, doctors can only control the angle at which the beam enters the body and how much radiation all the tissue in its path receives. With proton therapy, doctors can also decide where the beam should stop and release the majority of its energy.
For example, if a tumor is 4 centimeters beneath the surface of the patient’s skin, the radiologist can set the speed of the protons so they come to a stop exactly 4 centimeters after entering the patient’s body.
The science behind this is complex. The radiologist has to account for the different densities of the tissues in the body as well as the movement of the tumor when the patient breathes.
An experienced radiologist with the right proton therapy equipment has more control than they would with a traditional radiation machine. This means they can safely administer a higher dose of therapy, potentially killing more cancer cells.
Proton Therapy for Mesothelioma
The main barriers to proton therapy are the high cost of the equipment and the high level of expertise required to use it. Researchers have only recently had opportunities to explore the potential of proton therapy for mesothelioma patients.
In 2014, a retrospective study reviewed the outcomes for seven pleural mesothelioma patients. It confirmed proton therapy reduces the amount of radiation received by the lungs, heart, esophagus and liver compared to traditional radiation therapy.
In 2017, researchers reported on three case studies of pleural mesothelioma patients. Each received proton therapy after undergoing standard chemotherapy and then major surgery to remove a lung.
- A 71-year-old patient with stage 3 cancer survived for 25 months after multimodal treatment. At the 20th month, he also began receiving immunotherapy.
- A 47-year-old patient with stage 4 mesothelioma survived for only 4 months after multimodal treatment. During the surgery, the surgeons discovered his cancer had spread further than anticipated, making it more difficult to target with proton therapy.
- A 46-year-old patient with stage 3 cancer was still alive at the time of the study’s writing, 14 months after the multimodal treatment. There was no evidence of disease progression. The patient’s symptoms were manageable with physical therapy and medication.
For patients who undergo surgery while their cancer is still localized, proton therapy can help them survive far longer than the typical life expectancy.
Who Is Eligible for Proton Therapy?
Proton therapy is primarily recommended for patients with localized cancer. Unfortunately, mesothelioma is a rapidly spreading disease, and many patients are diagnosed in a late cancer stage.
Proton therapy is not an option for many patients.
To be eligible to receive proton therapy as part of an aggressive multimodal treatment approach, patients must also be in good enough overall health to withstand and recover from major surgery.
Other requirements to be a candidate for proton therapy include:
- Weight of under 360 pounds (equipment may not be able to accommodate larger patients)
- Ability to commute to or stay near the treatment facility for daily appointments
Mesothelioma is a rare type of cancer, and proton therapy remains an uncommon type of cancer treatment. To find a medical team that specializes in both, patients must seek treatment at a top cancer center. This may involve traveling long distances.
Proton therapy also remains a very expensive type of treatment.
This therapy is delivered in cycles of up to eight weeks. The length of treatment is dependent on the dose of radiation required to treat the cancer. Higher doses of radiation are given in shorter cycles. Lower doses of radiation are delivered over a longer period of time.
To prepare for the procedure, patients undergo a simulation session a week before treatments are set to begin.
During a therapy session, patients are positioned on a device that prevents the body from moving. Using markings made during the simulation session, the radiation therapist aims the radiation beam and administers the dose from a control room.
Throughout the 30- to 90-minute treatment sessions, patients can communicate with their radiation therapist via a two-way intercom. The procedure is painless and carries a low risk of side effects and complications.
9 Cited Article Sources
The sources on all content featured in The Mesothelioma Center at Asbestos.com include medical and scientific studies, peer-reviewed studies and other research documents from reputable organizations.
Lee, H. et al. (2017, September). Proton Therapy for Malignant Pleural Mesothelioma: A Three Case Series Describing the Clinical and Dosimetric Advantages of Proton-Based Therapy.
Retrieved from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319949385_Proton_Therapy_for_Malignant_Pleural_Mesothelioma_A_Three_Case_Series_Describing_the_Clinical_and_Dosimetric_Advantages_of_Proton-Based_Therapy
MedlinePlus. (2016, May 20). Proton therapy.
Retrieved from: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/007281.htm
Pan, H. et al. (2014, October 30). Early Experience with Intensity-Modulated Proton Therapy for Lung-Intact Mesothelioma: A Case Series.
Retrieved from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25572666/
National Association of Proton Therapy. (n.d.). How Does Proton Therapy Work?
Retrieved from: https://www.proton-therapy.org/science/
National Association for Proton Therapy. (2010, October 19). Pencil Beam Radiation Offers New Therapy Option for Lung Cancer Patients.
Retrieved from: http://www.proton-therapy.org/lungcancer_1010.html
Krayenbuehl, J. et al. (2010, October). Proton therapy for malignant pleural mesothelioma after extrapleural pneumonectomy.
Retrieved from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20385451
MD Anderson Cancer Center. (n.d.). Proton Therapy Center: What to Expect.
Retrieved from: http://www.mdanderson.org/patient-and-cancer-information/proton-therapy-center/what-to-expect/index.html
National Association for Proton Therapy. (n.d.). How It Works.
Retrieved from: http://www.proton-therapy.org/howit.htm
- UF Health Proton Therapy Institute. (n.d.).Proton Therapy for Cancer Treatment. Retrieved from: https://www.floridaproton.org/what-is-proton-therapy
How did this article help you?
What about this article isn’t helpful for you?
Did this article help you?
Share this article
Last Modified May 21, 2020