Mesothelioma Misdiagnosis & the Importance of a Second Opinion

Mesothelioma may be misdiagnosed as another cancer or in the wrong stage. Misdiagnosis causes doctors to prescribe the wrong treatments. Anyone with a history of asbestos exposure should get a second opinion from a mesothelioma specialist to properly identify and treat their condition.

Get a Free Mesothelioma Guide

Written By

Edited By

Medical Review By

This page features: 11 cited research articles

Malignant mesothelioma is a rare and complex cancer. Most physicians and many oncologists rarely see it and don’t fully understand how it works. A specialist is required to get an accurate mesothelioma diagnosis and the right treatment plan.

Mesothelioma Misdiagnosis
  • Most doctors are not familiar with asbestos-related diseases.

  • Early-stage meso thelioma is often mistaken for more common illnesses.

  • Many mesothelioma patients are misdiagnosed multiple times.

  • Misdiagnosis can delay cancer treatment for several months.

If you have a history of asbestos exposure and new chest-related symptoms, find a mesothelioma specialist. It is important to find a specialist who can diagnose or confirm your condition quickly. These doctors can tailor an effective treatment regimen to fit your personal needs.

“Mesothelioma is so complex, and its care so specialized, that a patient really needs the best care in the world,” said mesothelioma specialist and thoracic surgeon Dr. Abraham Lebenthal of Brigham and Women’s Hospital and the Boston VA. “This is not a knock on anyone, but many doctors only see one or two cases a year, and you don’t want to be on someone’s learning curve. Find the best. Find someone who sees this a lot.”

Talk to a Doctor About Your Diagnosis

We can connect you or a loved one with top mesothelioma doctors and cancer centers in your area.

Get Help Now

Common Misdiagnoses of Mesothelioma

Asbestos-related cancer is complex. There is no clear path to a mesothelioma diagnosis. Each case is unique and early mesothelioma symptoms often mirror those of less serious illnesses.

When an oncologist isn’t familiar with this disease, it can be easy to misread the early symptoms. This can delay the right diagnosis and treatment plan.

Video of Dr. David Sugarbaker, Chief of General Thoracic Surgery, explains why a mesothelioma misdiagnosis is so common.
Renowned mesothelioma thoracic surgeon Dr. David Sugarbaker explains why a mesothelioma misdiagnosis occurs so frequently.

The Wrong Illness

Many of mesothelioma’s initial symptoms can mimic those of a less serious illness and be dismissed at first. These symptoms may include a persistent cough, shortness of breath, chest discomfort and night sweats.

Pleural mesothelioma starts in the lining around the lungs. These patients are often first told they have pneumonia or asthma. Later they learn they had a much more serious illness brewing all along.

Initial symptoms of pleural mesothelioma may be diagnosed as other conditions including:
  • Emphysema

  • Bronchitis or other bronchial infections

  • Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)

Peritoneal mesothelioma starts in the lining around the abdominal cavity. These patients are often first told by physicians they have something as common as a hernia or irritable bowel syndrome. Eventually they learn they have a serious form of cancer.

Peritoneal mesothelioma survivor Kasie Coleman was misdiagnosed five times.

“First it was bruised ribs. Second was chlamydia. Then it was irritable bowel syndrome, then gallstones and finally ovarian cancer,” Coleman said. “I can’t tell you the amount of people I’ve talked to that are no longer here because they just accept the first thing their doctor tells them.”

The Wrong Cancer

Even when a general oncologist makes a cancer diagnosis, their first suspect is often a more common form of cancer.

For example, pleural mesothelioma can be misdiagnosed as lung cancer. Peritoneal mesothelioma can be misdiagnosed as ovarian cancer or colon cancer.

Get a Free Mesothelioma Guide

Detailed mesothelioma information, books, wristbands and more for patients and caregivers.

Get Yours Today

Mesothelioma can also be misdiagnosed as adenocarcinoma, a cancer that forms in the mucus-secreting glands in the body.

Peritoneal mesothelioma survivor Karen Frantz was first diagnosed with stage 3 ovarian cancer. A second surgery revealed her true diagnosis.

“Mesothelioma can be a frightening reality to be faced with. The chance of recovery may seem grim,” Frantz said. “But do not give up on life. When things look hopeless, you still can get through with a faith in God.”

Benign mesothelioma must also be ruled out with pathology tests. These tests look at biopsy samples under a microscope to tell one cancer apart from another.

Within mesothelioma itself, the types of mesothelioma cells vary. Patients may have epithelioid mesothelioma or sarcomatoid mesothelioma. Some patients have a mixture of the two. The cell type has a major impact on their prognosis and treatment options.

The Wrong Stage

It is also possible to misdiagnose the stage of the cancer. Staging is a way to measure how far the cancer has progressed. It plays a central role in determining an accurate prognosis for the disease and what types of treatments are appropriate.

The earlier the stage of the cancer, the tougher it will be to diagnose. Finding it earlier gives you more treatment options and a better chance at long-term survival. It’s another reason why seeing a specialist early in the process is so important.

Importance of Getting a Second Opinion

If you have a history of asbestos exposure, seek a second opinion from a mesothelioma specialist if you get symptoms in the chest or abdomen.

It is all too common for the initial symptoms of mesothelioma to be misdiagnosed as something less serious. Those with a history of asbestos exposure should always take any health changes seriously.

People diagnosed with mesothelioma should especially get a second opinion from an expert. The average oncologist won’t have the right experience to accurately diagnose and treat your cancer.

Many unspecialized oncologists will get the cancer right, but they misgauge the stage. Mesothelioma specialists know the right tests to get an accurate stage. This makes all the difference to getting the most effective treatment.

A second opinion from a mesothelioma doctor also gets you access to pathologists who specialize in mesothelioma. Pathologists are the doctors who look at your biopsy samples in the lab. They’re the ones who ultimately confirm whether you have mesothelioma or some other cancer.

Mesothelioma doctors know which pathologists specialize in mesothelioma. They’ll only send your biopsy samples to the best pathologists to make sure your diagnosis is correct.

If you have mesothelioma, a second opinion is crucial to getting the right treatment.

Where to Find a Specialist

It may be easy to ask a family member or friend for a good referral when looking for a family doctor, but finding a mesothelioma specialist is not so simple.

Only 2,000 to 3,000 patients are diagnosed with mesothelioma in the U.S. each year. There are few specialists and cancer centers with the resources and experience to give mesothelioma patients a fighting chance.

Dr. Fontaine explains why choosing a mesothelioma specialist is so important.

Find a Specialist Near You

8 Results Found in

Dr. Vadim Gushchin, Surgical Oncologist

Vadim Gushchin, M.D.

Peritoneal Surface Malignancies

Mercy Medical Center
Dr. Kiran Turaga, Surgical Oncologist

Kiran Turaga, M.D.

Surgical Treatment of Abdominal and Peritoneal Diseases

University of Chicago Comprehensive Cancer Center
Dr. Aaron Mansfield - Medical Oncologist

Aaron S. Mansfield, M.D.

Lung Cancer and Mesothelioma Immunotherapy

Mayo Clinic Minnesota
Dr. Robert Ramirez, Medical Oncologist

Robert Ramirez, M.D.

Lung Cancer, Pleural Mesothelioma, Research

Ochsner Medical Center
Dr. Jack A. Elias, Chairman of the Department of Internal Medicine at Yale University

Jack A. Elias, M.D.

Internal Medicine: Pulmonary & Critical Care Medicine

Yale New Haven Health Smilow Cancer Hospital
Dr. W. Charles Conway, Director of Surgical Oncology & Expert Contributor for Asbestos.com

W. Charles Conway, M.D.

Peritoneal surface malignancies, complex oncologic surgeries

Ridley-Tree Cancer Center
Dr. Brian Pettiford, Cardiothoracic Surgeon & Expert Contributor for Asbestos.com

Brian Pettiford, M.D.

Pleural Mesothelioma, Lung Cancer

Ochsner Medical Center
Dr. Miguel Alvelo-Rivera, Thoracic Surgical Oncologist

Miguel Alvelo-Rivera, M.D.

Minimally Invasive Thoracic Surgery

Henry Ford Hospital
Dr. Betty Tong, Cardiothoracic Surgeon

Betty Tong, M.D.

Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery

Duke Cancer Center
Dr. Nathan Pennell, Medical Oncologist

Nathan Pennell, M.D.

Mesothelioma, Lung Cancer, Clinical Trials

Cleveland Clinic Cancer Institute
Dr. Neil Christie, Assistant Professor of Surgery

Neil Christie, M.D.

Minimally Invasive Thoracic Surgery

UPMC Hillman Cancer Center

Don't see your state? Find out how our Doctor Match program can help.

Learn More

Don't see your state? Find out how our Doctor Match program can help. Learn More

How Do Specialists Diagnose Mesothelioma?

Several factors help doctors identify mesothelioma including:

  • Potential history of asbestos exposure (reviewing a patient’s work history)

  • Pathology tests looking for specific mesothelioma cell types

  • Imaging tests such as X-rays and PET scans

  • Blood tests looking for mesothelioma biomarkers

  • Genetic tests looking for mutations associated with mesothelioma

“Don’t take no for an answer. Pay attention to your body.”

Kasie Coleman, diagnosed with peritoneal mesothelioma in 2010

The process of diagnosing mesothelioma often starts with X-rays and other imaging tests such as CT and MRI scans.

Fluid buildup around the lungs or in the abdomen can point to many diseases. But if it recurs after being drained, more tests should be done for a possible mesothelioma diagnosis.

A specialist may use a thin needle to remove fluid for analysis. This procedure is called a thoracentesis for pleural patients. It is called a paracentesis for peritoneal mesothelioma patients. Doctors search the fluid for certain types of cells and proteins to look for clues to a serious illness.

The next step for pleural patients is often a thoracoscopy. This is also known as video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS). This procedure usually requires an overnight hospital stay. A doctor inserts a small camera and a special probe through small incisions in the chest to remove a biopsy sample of tumor tissue.

There are several other types of biopsy procedures doctors may use depending on the location of the tumor tissue. After the biopsy sample is taken, a pathologist reviews it under a microscope to identify the cancer and its cell type.

An Accurate Diagnosis Leads to the Best Treatment Options

Treatment options are based on the diagnosis. In most cases, if a diagnosis is wrong, so is the treatment.

If you have a history of asbestos exposure, make sure you discuss it with your doctor. Be attentive to warning signs that may be early mesothelioma symptoms. If they persist after a short period, take action.

The sooner your diagnosis is confirmed, the sooner a specialist can develop a treatment plan. Patients diagnosed in an early stage usually qualify for more aggressive treatment options. Aggressive treatment has a higher chance of extending life expectancy.

An accurate diagnosis changed everything about peritoneal mesothelioma survivor Darlene Micciche’s treatment and prognosis.

She was originally misdiagnosed with pancreatic cancer. Seeking a second opinion changed her diagnosis to peritoneal mesothelioma. She got the right surgery and chemotherapy for her true cancer and now enjoys spending time with family and friends.

“For two weeks, I thought I had stage 4 pancreatic cancer,” Micciche said. “When they finally told me it was mesothelioma, I actually felt relieved. That was better than the diagnosis we originally thought I had.”

Multimodal Therapy

Surgery to remove the tumor is considered the best treatment option for living longer with this disease. But it is typically only an option if the cancer hasn’t spread too far and the patient is in good overall health. Surgery is usually performed as part of a multimodal approach. Multimodal treatment combines surgery with chemotherapy, radiation therapy or another treatment modality.

Clinical Trials

Experimental treatments have shown promising initial results for mesothelioma patients. Examples include photodynamic therapy and immunotherapy. Patients can access emerging therapies by participating in clinical trials. Eligibility usually depends on the stage and type of cancer.

Palliative Treatment

If a patient’s cancer has progressed to a late stage and spread throughout the body, aggressive treatment may do more harm than good. Specialists can instead focus on palliative care. This kind of care involves alleviating symptoms and increasing quality of life. Complementary and alternative medicines may also benefit the patient.

Mesothelioma Misdiagnosis & the Importance of a Second Opinion
Get Help Contacting Mesothelioma Misdiagnosis & the Importance of a Second Opinion

Are You Feeling Overwhelmed by Mesothelioma?

We Can Help
Asbestos.com Mesothelioma Packet

Get Answers in Our Free Mesothelioma Guide

Order Yours Now

Our Patient Advocates Help Get the Resources You Need

Connect With Us

Get Answers to Your Mesothelioma Questions

Get Your Free Mesothelioma Guide

Connect With a Trusted Patient Advocate

Did this article help you?

Did this article help you?

Thank you for your feedback. Would you like to speak with a Patient Advocate?


Karen Selby, RN and Patient Advocate at The Mesothelioma Center

Karen Selby joined Asbestos.com in 2009. She is a registered nurse with a background in oncology and thoracic surgery and was the director of a tissue bank before becoming a Patient Advocate at The Mesothelioma Center. Karen has assisted surgeons with thoracic surgeries such as lung resections, lung transplants, pneumonectomies, pleurectomies and wedge resections. She is also a member of the Academy of Oncology Nurse & Patient Navigators. Read More

Reviewed by placeholder

Medical Review By

Last Modified June 20, 2018
Sources
  1. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. (n.d.). Getting a second opinion before surgery.  

  2. Retrieved from: https://www.medicare.gov/what-medicare-covers/part-b/second-opinions-before-surgery.html 
  3. Dana-Farber Cancer Institute. (2014, May 20). Getting a second opinion about your cancer care.  

  4. Retrieved from: http://blog.dana-farber.org/insight/2013/02/getting-a-second-opinion-about-your-cancer-care/ 
  5. Andrews, M. (2015). Second opinions are often sought, but their value isn't clear.  

  6. Retrieved from: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/05/26/408832997/second-opinions-are-often-sought-but-their-value-isnt-clear 
  7. Hancock, K.L. et al. (2016). A case of mesothelioma masquerading pre-operatively as ovarian cancer and brief review of the literature. Gynecol Oncol Rep., 17, 26–28. doi: 10.1016/j.gore.2016.04.003
  8. Zandwijk, N. et al. (2013). Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of malignant pleural mesothelioma. J Thorac Dis., 5(6), E254–E307. doi: 10.3978/j.issn.2072-1439.2013.11.28
  9. Cleveland Clinic. (2014, November 18). Why you should consider a second medical opinion. for Medicare and Medicaid Services. (n.d.). Getting a second opinion before surgery.  
    Retrieved from: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/2014/11/why-you-should-consider-a-second-medical-opinion/ Centers

  10. Retrieved from: https://www.medicare.gov/what-medicare-covers/part-b/second-opinions-before-surgery.html 
  11. Dana-Farber Cancer Institute. (2014, May 20). Getting a second opinion about your cancer care.  

  12. Retrieved from: http://blog.dana-farber.org/insight/2013/02/getting-a-second-opinion-about-your-cancer-care/ 
  13. Andrews, M. (2015). Second opinions are often sought, but their value isn't clear.  

  14. Retrieved from: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/05/26/408832997/second-opinions-are-often-sought-but-their-value-isnt-clear 
  15. Hancock, K.L. et al. (2016). A case of mesothelioma masquerading pre-operatively as ovarian cancer and brief review of the literature. Gynecol Oncol Rep., 17, 26–28. doi: 10.1016/j.gore.2016.04.003
  16. Zandwijk, N. et al. (2013). Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of malignant pleural mesothelioma. J Thorac Dis., 5(6), E254–E307. doi: 10.3978/j.issn.2072-1439.2013.11.28
  17. Cleveland Clinic. (2014, November 18). Why you should consider a second medical opinion. Retrieved from: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/2014/11/why-you-should-consider-a-second-medical-opinion/ 
Topics on This Page
Back to Top
Chat live with a patient advocate now loading spinner