Helping Veterans Appeal Denied Mesothelioma Claims
1:04

Exclusive Content

Aaron Munz:

Why the VA Denies Mesothelioma and Asbestos Claims

Most VA mesothelioma claims get denied for 1 of 2 reasons. Understanding those reasons is the first step toward a stronger appeal. The most common reason for denial is a missing or weak medical nexus letter. A “nexus letter” is a medical opinion showing that your exposure to asbestos in the military likely led to your mesothelioma diagnosis. Getting at least 1 nexus letter can take a lot of time and effort on your part, and your medical practitioner needs to write a letter that meets very specific standards.

The second reason is unproven service-connected exposure. Veterans need to show that their exposure to asbestos while in the military is at least 50% of the reason they developed mesothelioma. Like obtaining nexus letters, getting all of your work history and details of your asbestos exposure can be a challenge.

These two factors may also lead to an approved claim with a low disability rating. That can also be appealed.

Expert Insight

“When a Veteran has been denied benefits by the VA, we can help them understand why the VA denied the claim.”

Aaron Munz , Director of Veterans Department, The Mesothelioma Center

What Are Your Options After a Denied Mesothelioma VA Claim?

After a denial, veterans with mesothelioma can use 1 of 3 decision review options established under the Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act. Each option serves a different purpose, and veterans can escalate from one to another if needed. Our Patient Advocates can help you determine which path best fits your situation.

Supplemental Claim

A Supplemental Claim works in 1 of 2 ways. Veterans can provide new evidence supporting their claims, or, if relevant laws have changed, they can request a review based on that. For VA mesothelioma claims, the new evidence option often means providing a stronger nexus letter from a specialist or more proof that your asbestos exposure while in the military led to your diagnosis. If new evidence exists, this is usually the right first step.

Higher-Level Review

A Higher-Level Review sends the original claim, using only the existing evidence, to a senior VA reviewer who can look for legal or factual errors. Veterans can request an informal conference in which they or a representative can point out errors to a higher-level reviewer. That reviewer decides if a mistake was made or if they have a different opinion than the initial reviewer, either of which can change the results of your claim. This option works best when you believe the VA made a mistake while examining the evidence already on file.

Board Appeal

A Board Appeal takes the case to a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals. You can choose between having the judge review your claim as-is, submitting additional evidence for them to consider, or going through a hearing. A board appeal can take longer than the other options, but it’s the right move when earlier reviews haven’t resolved the denial.

Board Appeal Options

OptionWhat it isNew evidence?Best when
Board AppealCase goes to a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (direct review, evidence submission or hearing)Depends on chosen appeals methodEarlier reviews failed, you want your case reviewed by a judge, and/or you want a hearing
Higher-Level ReviewSenior reviewer re-examines the same evidence; informal conference optionalNoYou believe the VA made an error with evidence already on file
Supplemental ClaimAdd new and relevant evidence that the VA hasn’t seenYesYou have a stronger nexus letter or fuller exposure summary

How to Strengthen Your VA Mesothelioma Appeal

A strong VA appeal comes down to the quality of the evidence. Most denials happen because the VA didn’t have enough medical or exposure documentation to approve the claim. You need to prove that your mesothelioma is at least 50% connected to asbestos exposure from the time you were in the military. The good news is that gaps in evidence may be fixable, but gathering all of the information you need can be challenging. A VA-accredited representative can help veterans gather the necessary documents and file the right decision review at no cost.

Evidence That Helps

  • A detailed asbestos exposure summary covering when, how and where exposure occurred during military service
  • A nexus letter from a mesothelioma specialist linking the diagnosis to service-connected asbestos exposure
  • Example nexus language veterans can bring to their doctor
  • New and relevant documentation such as service records, ship or unit data, buddy statements and updated medical records

Getting this evidence together takes time, especially with a mesothelioma diagnosis. The stronger the documentation, the better the chances of a successful appeal.

Expert Insight

“The most common challenges that veterans face when applying for veterans benefits with the VA are providing the correct medical information about their diagnosis, providing a medical nexus statement from their specialist, which connects their current diagnosis to exposure to asbestos. The other thing that many veterans don’t realize is that they must also prove that the majority of their lifetime exposure to asbestos occurred on active duty.”

Aaron Munz , Director of Veterans Department at The Mesothelioma Center

Deadlines for Appealing a VA Mesothelioma Claim

Veterans generally have 1 year from the date on their VA decision letter to file an appeal. Filing within that window protects the original effective date, which affects how far back benefits can be paid. Missing the deadline doesn’t always mean starting over, but it can mean losing back pay that a veteran has earned.

With a mesothelioma diagnosis, time is especially important. Waiting too long to gather all of your evidence can narrow the number of options available. Veterans may qualify for expedited processing given the severity of the diagnosis, so it’s worth asking a VA-accredited claims agent about that option early.

Key Deadline

Veterans generally have 1 year from the date of their VA decision letter to file a Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal. A Supplemental Claim can be filed at any time, but filing within that 1-year window protects the original effective date and back pay.

Appealing a VA Mesothelioma Claim After a Veteran Dies

A surviving spouse or dependent can appeal a denied VA mesothelioma claim after a veteran passes. The appeals process is the same as it is for veterans, and the core requirement doesn’t change: showing that the veteran’s mesothelioma was connected to military service. Survivors can also pursue Dependency and Indemnity Compensation if the veteran’s death relates to a service-connected condition.

The DIC program has its own unique eligibility requirements and benefit details. Families navigating a denial after a veteran’s death don’t have to do it alone. Our Veterans Department works with surviving family members at no cost.

As VA-Accredited Claims Agent, Veteran and Director of Veterans Department at The Mesothelioma Center, Aaron Munz explains, “The Mesothelioma Center is different from other organizations that help veterans with VA claims issues because we are experts at asbestos. We have a team of professionals that can help address medical, benefits and treatment options.”

How We Help You Appeal Your Mesothelioma VA Claim

The Mesothelioma Center’s Veterans Department helps veterans and their families understand a denial, gather the right evidence and file for the correct type of decision review. Our work includes drafting exposure summaries, obtaining nexus letters and identifying which appeal option fits the situation, all at no cost.

Our team is veteran-led and VA-accredited, with experience helping veterans navigate the unique challenges of asbestos-related VA claims. We’ve worked with Veterans Service Officers across the country and understand what the VA needs to approve a mesothelioma claim.

Most veterans and families don’t need to hire a law firm to appeal a denial. Our team handles the evidence-gathering and paperwork so veterans can focus on treatment and time with family. We also connect veterans and survivors with medical specialists, treatment centers and support resources through The Mesothelioma Center’s broader network. If the VA denied your claim or assigned a rating that doesn’t reflect the severity of your diagnosis, we can help you understand your options and take the next step.

FREE VA CLAIMS ASSISTANCE
Compensation for Veterans Exposed to Asbestos

We can help you or a loved one file asbestos-related VA claims and access potential benefits.

Get Help Now

Common Questions About Appealing a Denied VA Mesothelioma Claim

Is it worth appealing a denied VA mesothelioma claim?

Yes. Many asbestos claims get denied for fixable reasons, such as a missing nexus letter, and are later approved on appeal. There’s no penalty for filing and accredited help is available at no cost.

How long does a VA mesothelioma appeal take?

How long a mesothelioma appeal takes depends on the type of appeal you pursue. A Supplemental Claim or Higher-Level Review is generally faster than a Board Appeal. A veteran with mesothelioma may qualify for expedited processing, so it’s worth asking a VA-accredited claims agent about that option early in the process.

Does it cost anything to appeal a VA decision?

Filing a VA appeal is free. The Mesothelioma Center’s VA-accredited claims agents also provide help at no cost. Attorneys may charge a fee only if past-due benefits are awarded.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal a denied VA mesothelioma claim?

No. Veterans can appeal without legal representation, but appeals are often more successful when they have an expert’s help. A VA-accredited representative can assemble the medical and exposure evidence the VA requires at no cost. Legal representation is an option, not a requirement.

Can I appeal if the VA rated my mesothelioma too low?

Yes. If the VA approved the claim but assigned a rating below 100%, that rating can be appealed. Active mesothelioma typically qualifies for a 100% rating. A Higher-Level Review or Supplemental Claim can correct an underrating.

Recommended Reading