Legal Fight Continues Over Asbestos Disease in Libby, Mont.

Asbestos Exposure & Bans

Written by Tim Povtak

Reading Time: 4 mins
Publication Date: 03/05/2021
Fact Checked
Our fact-checking process begins with a thorough review of all sources to ensure they are high quality. Then we cross-check the facts with original medical or scientific reports published by those sources, or we validate the facts with reputable news organizations, medical and scientific experts and other health experts. Each page includes all sources for full transparency.
Reviewed is the nation’s most trusted mesothelioma resource

The Mesothelioma Center at has provided patients and their loved ones the most updated and reliable information on mesothelioma and asbestos exposure since 2006.

Our team of Patient Advocates includes a medical doctor, a registered nurse, health services administrators, veterans, VA-accredited Claims Agents, an oncology patient navigator and hospice care expert. Their combined expertise means we help any mesothelioma patient or loved one through every step of their cancer journey.

More than 30 contributors, including mesothelioma doctors, survivors, health care professionals and other experts, have peer-reviewed our website and written unique research-driven articles to ensure you get the highest-quality medical and health information.

About The Mesothelioma Center at

  • Assisting mesothelioma patients and their loved ones since 2006.
  • Helps more than 50% of mesothelioma patients diagnosed annually in the U.S.
  • A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
  • 5-star reviewed mesothelioma and support organization.
Learn More About Us


"My family has only the highest compliment for the assistance and support that we received from The Mesothelioma Center. This is a staff of compassionate and knowledgeable individuals who respect what your family is experiencing and who go the extra mile to make an unfortunate diagnosis less stressful. Information and assistance were provided by The Mesothelioma Center at no cost to our family."
Mesothelioma patient’s daughter
  • Google Review Rating
  • BBB Review Rating

How to Cite’s Article


Povtak, T. (2021, March 5). Legal Fight Continues Over Asbestos Disease in Libby, Mont.. Retrieved March 25, 2023, from


Povtak, Tim. "Legal Fight Continues Over Asbestos Disease in Libby, Mont..", 5 Mar 2021,


Povtak, Tim. "Legal Fight Continues Over Asbestos Disease in Libby, Mont.." Last modified March 5, 2021.

Welcome sign in Libby, Montana

The Center for Asbestos Related Disease in Libby, Montana, dodged a potential setback recently when officials from the U.S. Department of Justice decided against joining a lawsuit alleging fraudulent medical practices.

Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway filed the original suit in 2019 against the center – known as the CARD Clinic – alleging Medicare fraud that included unnecessary screenings and misdiagnosing patients with various asbestos-related diseases.

The railroad giant is facing more than a thousand asbestos-related injury claims stemming from its transportation of asbestos-laden products through its railyard from the nearby W.R. Grace & Co. vermiculite mine decades ago.

Part of its defense involves discrediting the CARD Clinic, a community nonprofit health organization that evolved from the widespread asbestos contamination and resulting diseases that have been part of the Libby area for decades.

The most serious disease has been pleural mesothelioma cancer, which is caused almost exclusively by exposure to asbestos.

CARD Clinic Saving Lives for a Decade

Libby is home to the longest-running human-made environmental disaster in U.S. history, where toxic asbestos was mined for more than 70 years. Although the mine closed more than 20 years ago, new cases still are being diagnosed today, primarily because of the lengthy latency period of asbestos diseases such as mesothelioma.

The Card Clinic staff includes a variety of asbestos disease specialists such as researchers, nurses, doctors and respiratory therapists.

BNSF Railway filed a whistleblower-type lawsuit that allows entities with evidence of fraud against a federal program to sue the alleged perpetrator. The federal government has the option to join, and considerably strengthen, the filing.

Federal Government Will Not Intervene in Libby

After almost a year of investigating, the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General decided not to get involved, although it still could at a later date.

In its official determination paper, the Department of Justice said its decision “should not be construed as a statement about the merits of the case.”

A spokeswoman for BNSF said the company intends to proceed with the case on its own.

The suit contends that “novel lung conditions” have been detectable only by CARD Clinic professionals. Much of the CARD funding for diagnosis and treatment comes from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, a federal agency.

BNSF’s suit also points to widely conflicting diagnostics involving radiologists not affiliated with the CARD Clinic, some of which found no asbestos-related disease in patients.

In the past 10 years, the CARD Clinic has conducted more than 3,500 lung cancer and mesothelioma cancer screenings and 7,000 asbestos health screenings, according to the Daily Inter Lake, a newspaper in nearby Kalispell, Montana.

Officials at the CARD Clinic have staunchly defended the work being done there for years.

“The government’s decision not to prosecute on behalf of BNSF is a telling indication that the claims against CARD are largely a fabrication,” attorney Timothy Bechtold, who is representing the clinic, told the Daily Inter Lake. “I think that the most cynical view you can take when it comes to BNSF is accurate. They are a corporation, and they have corporate interests. They don’t care about the people in Libby.”

Montana Supreme Court Holds BNSF Responsible

Bechtold also told the Daily Inter Lake the lawsuit is an attempt to halt the diagnosing of asbestos-related diseases by closing the CARD Clinic, which would cap future liabilities.

In 2020, the Montana Supreme Court reaffirmed a lower court finding and ruled that BNSF Railway should be held liable for its role in adding to the contamination of Libby with toxic asbestos.

BNSF Railway had argued that federal regulations governing railroads protect it from liability issues, but the high court disagreed. The extent of the liability, though, was not specific.

“The decision to pursue this litigation was not taken lightly,” a BNSF spokeswoman told the Daily Inter Lake. “BNSF found very concerning allegations of fraud related to work at the Center for Asbestos Related Disease, Inc.”

paper with magnifying glass
Free Mesothelioma Resources
Get Access to Free Resources for Patients & Loved Ones